Programs Animals in Laboratories Strengthening Laws, Regulations, and Enforcement Cases Against Chronic Violators

Case: Moulton Chinchilla Ranch

Other pages in this section

Overview

On October 8, 2021, an administrative law judge permanently revoked the dealer license of Dan Moulton, owner of Moulton Chinchilla Ranch (MCR), one of the nation’s primary suppliers of chinchillas for experimentation. For years, AWI has been raising concerns about the abysmal conditions at MCR, which for decades has sold its chinchillas to research facilities around the country, and calling out the US Department of Agriculture for failing to prevent the suffering of animals by enforcing the AWA.

On October 8, 2021 an administrative law judge permanently revoked the dealer license of Dan Moulton, owner of Moulton Chinchilla Ranch (MCR), one of the nation’s primary suppliers of chinchillas for experimentation.

Following an 18-day hearing, US Department of Agriculture Administrative Law Judge Jill Clifton deemed Moulton “unfit” to hold an AWA license and described his animal welfare violations as “absolutely astounding.” She also fined him $18,000. This is only the second time in 18 years that an administrative law judge has rendered an oral decision under the AWA from the bench, underscoring the severity of Moulton’s violations related to animals’ health, sanitation, and safety.

For years, AWI has been raising concerns about the abysmal conditions at MCR, which sells its chinchillas to research facilities around the country, and calling out the US Department of Agriculture for failing to prevent the suffering of animals by enforcing the AWA. Since 2014, Moulton has amassed the worst animal care record of the 10,000+ entities regulated under the law, as USDA inspectors have documented. Yet the USDA, the research industry, and state and local law enforcement repeatedly refused to act, even after MCR had been cited for more than 100 AWA violations on USDA inspection reports.

Moulton has publicly stated he is considering appealing the judge’s decision. Such appeals can drag on for years. AWI appreciates the judge’s action, but it does not excuse the USDA’s longstanding failure to protect these animals. The chinchillas should have been seized years ago, as prescribed under the Animal Welfare Act, to prevent further harm.

AWI will be closely monitoring developments in this case. Further information about MCR’s record, USDA inspections and photos, and media coverage are below.

2021 USDA Hearing

Case name: In re: DANIEL J. MOULTON, an individual, also known as DAN MOULTON, doing business as MOULTON CHINCHILLA RANCH
Case number: AWA DOCKET 19-0004

The hearing spanned four weeks over a four-month period:
July 26–30, August 9–13, and September 20–October 8

Court Documents

Summary of Allegations Against MCR

The complaint (see below) alleges more than 80 separate instances of failure to provide veterinary care and the repeated failure to provide USDA inspectors with access to the premises to assess the dealer’s compliance with the AWA. In addition, the complaint cites repeated failure to remove excessive build-up of excreta, food waste, shavings, dust, water, fur, and dead animals in the cages, as well as failure to maintain structurally sound enclosures, provide adequate lighting, use clean water receptacles, employ a sufficient number of staff, and control flies.

USDA Court Filings (Obtained by FOIA)

Background

AWI Coverage of MCR

Media Coverage

Photos

Photos and captions from USDA inspections of Moulton Chincilla Ranch.

PHOTOS WITH CAPTIONS

Hundreds of additional photos taken during inspections are available below.

2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020

USDA Inspection Reports

MCR operates as a USDA-liscensed dealer, # 41-B-0239

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014